Skip to main content

Tag: sport

When the Legacy Presents its Bill

Seven months have passed since the end of the Milan-Cortina Winter Olympics, and the record medal haul achieved by the Italian delegation will undoubtedly remain one of the finest sporting memories in our country’s history. Now that the spotlight has faded, the focus on the impact of this mega-event on the urban and, in particular, mountain areas that characterised the competition period has now completely fallen out of the spotlight of the media, politicians and the public, yet the situation is far from positive.

For years, the word legacy was one of the most frequently used – often in a thoroughly overused manner – to describe the positive impact the Winter Olympics were expected to have on local areas. Not just a major sporting event, but an opportunity to modernise infrastructure, improve transport links, boost tourism and leave behind a legacy destined to last well beyond 2026. Today, it is already possible to begin viewing that promise from a different perspective. It is clearly not yet a definitive assessment; indeed, many projects have yet to be completed, some economic effects can only be assessed in the medium to long term, and various pieces of infrastructure have yet to find a genuine place in the daily life of the local communities, but certain elements are already beginning to take shape.

A future far greater than the Games

According to SIMICO, the ‘Società Infrastrutture Milano Cortina’, the Works Plan comprised a total of 98 projects, with a total value of approximately 3.5 billion euros. Of these, 47 concerned sports facilities and 51 transport infrastructure; of the 98 projects in total, 67 are classified as legacy projects, therefore intended to remain in the region beyond the Olympic event [1]. This is certainly a significant figure because it highlights a fundamental characteristic of the Milan-Cortina project: the initial promise that a large part of the investment would not be allocated directly to staging the competitions.

Even before the Games began, the Ministry of Infrastructure had presented the legacy as one of the central elements of the Olympic project: accessibility, mobility, urban regeneration, sports infrastructure, skills development and tourism were expected to yield benefits in the years to come [2]. The official sustainability strategy of the Milano Cortina 2026 Foundation had also placed the legacy at the heart of the project, with the stated aim of amplifying the positive effects of the event and engaging local communities in a long-term process [3].

The infrastructure bill

The total cost of this Games is and will be one of the most difficult issues to resolve; according to a recent analysis published by the italian newspaper Avvenire, the initial budget for major works, estimated at around €1.5 billion at the time of the bid, is said to have risen to nearly €6 billion, taking into account all infrastructure projects [4]. To further complicate matters, a new item of expenditure has emerged in recent days. The 17th of September, the Council of Ministers approved a decree-law providing for the transfer of a further €150 million to the Milano-Cortina 2026 Foundation, officially in order to “ensure the organisation’s budgetary balance” [5]. The measure was included (or hidden) in the decree dedicated to economic support and mitigating the effects of rising fuel costs.

However, these figures must clearly be treated with caution, as not all infrastructure projects can be regarded solely as an Olympic cost. Many are wider-ranging initiatives, included in the Plan precisely because they are intended to remain in place after the Games. The question, therefore, is not merely how much the Milan–Cortina project has cost, but what value the projects will actually generate in the years to come, and in this regard, transparency of data remains essential.

The Open Olympics campaign, coordinated by the Italian association “Libera” alongside a network of civic and environmental organisations, has been monitoring this very aspect since the preparatory phase. It also contributed to the launch of the Open Milano Cortina portal, which now publishes data on the projects and their progress [6]. In its third report (dated December 2025), the network again highlighted incomplete information on costs, funding, progress and environmental impact. One particularly significant finding concerned the timetable: according to the analysis of the available data, only 42 projects were due to be completed before the Games, whilst the completion of numerous other projects was scheduled for subsequent years, with some projects not due to be finished until as late as 2033 [6].

In Cortina, for example, the Olympic infrastructure continues to be at the centre of political debate. Town councillor Roberta De Zanna stated in an interview with the newspaper Il Dolomiti that a section of the community feels it has been marginalised by the changes brought about by the Games [7]. Among the issues raised are the costs of the bobsleigh track and the Apollonio–Socrepes cable car, as well as the relationship between major events, high-end tourism and residents’ quality of life [7]; the legacy is therefore not necessarily positive simply because a piece of infrastructure remains. The same issue has arisen in Bormio in Valtellina, where an investigation by il Fatto Quotidiano reported the serious concerns of the company managing the local ski facilities, according to which the 2025/26 season would have been the worst in terms of visitor numbers on the slopes, with around 275,000 first-time admissions, 100,000 fewer than the historical average [8].

A legacy that will have to contend with a changing climate

The infrastructures built for these Olympic Games will have to operate in mountain environments that, in the coming decades, will be very different from those for which they were designed. For this reason, the sustainability of a facility cannot be assessed solely on the basis of energy efficiency or the use of more sustainable materials; it must also be considered in relation to the long-term viability of the economic and environmental model it underpins. Now that the Games have concluded, a significant part of this environmental assessment has yet to be clearly defined. Indeed, the fourth report of the Open Olympics 2026 campaign notes that the carbon footprint figures for the construction sites and events are not yet available [6]. Without this data, it is difficult to understand the actual climate cost of the works carried out and the impact of the various stages of their construction and this is the most important point when discussing legacy.

Figure 1: View of Bormio (Lombardy) in winter. Image by Federico Arnaboldi from Pexels.

Just a couple of telling examples are the damage caused by the construction of the new bobsleigh track in Cortina, which involved extensive work on a wooded area, resulting in the felling of hundreds of centuries-old larch trees; and the construction of a huge artificial reservoir in Livigno with a capacity of around 203,000 cubic metres of water at an altitude of 2,600 metres, which had a severe impact on the already fragile hydrogeological and ecological balance that this part of the Alps is facing.

The Olympics can certainly leave behind efficient and modern infrastructure, but if this is situated in an area with an increasingly uncertain water supply, a more precarious snow season and growing pressure from tourism, its future usefulness cannot be taken for granted. The same reasoning applies to transport infrastructure: new roads and links can improve accessibility to mountain areas and alleviate some issues of isolation, but they can also increase tourist pressure, private vehicle traffic and, consequently, air pollution, if they are not accompanied by a structural strengthening of public transport.  The capacity of this infrastructure to support a transition towards a spatial model compatible with the changes the Alps are already facing.

Milan–Cortina had promised to leave Italy with something more than just medals; now is the time for that promise to be kept. Not through new slogans, but through data, financial statements, monitoring and, above all, through what will remain in the local areas once the memory of the Games has faded.

References:

Click here to expand the references [1] https://www.simico.it/piano-delle-opere/

[2] https://www.mit.gov.it/comunicazione/news/93-giorni-alle-olimpiadi-la-legacy-italiana-dei-giochi

[3] https://www.olympics.com/it/notizie/online-il-secondo-rapporto-di-sostenibilita-impatto-e-legacy-di-fondazione-milano-cortina-2026

[4] https://www.avvenire.it/attualita/i-conti-leredita-e-la-grande-vetrina-ecco-il-vero-bilancio-di-milano-cortina_113246

[5] https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2026/09/17/olimpiadi-milano-cortina-regalo-150-milioni-debiti-notizie/8509787/

[6] https://www.libera.it/it-schede-2753-la_campagna_open_olympics_2026

[7] https://www.ildolomiti.it/cronaca/2026/la-comunita-ha-sacrificato-tanto-sullaltare-delle-olimpiadi-ora-e-stufa-di-sentir-parlare-di-turismo-extralusso-e-grandi-eventi-occorre-un-cambio-di-rotta

[8] https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2026/09/08/bormio-olimpiadi-peggiore-stagione-collegamento-livigno-santa-caterina-notizie/8497700/

Cover and preview image: Winter image of Cortina d’Ampezzo. Photo by MARTINOPHUC on Pixabay.

Reuse Before Recycling

A football boot can have a surprisingly short career: a child outgrows it, a new model comes out, a sole starts to wear down, or perhaps it simply sits forgotten in a garage until one day it ends up in a bin. For being something designed to withstand thousands of steps, sprints and tackles, the final whistle for them can come remarkably early. In County Durham (north-east of England) a social enterprise is trying to change that. Re:Play Football collects pre-loved football boots, restores them and puts them back into circulation, giving them another chance on the pitch rather than sending them to landfill.

The initiative highlights how the County Durham-based organisation is tackling football’s often overlooked waste problem [1]. At first glance, the idea seems simple: take an old pair of boots and find someone who can still use them. But behind that apparently straightforward solution lies a much bigger question about how sustainable football can become. According to Re:Play, around 13 million pairs of football boots end up in UK landfill every year [2]. The organisation was founded after Ben Fisher and Jon Dennis, whose sons played for the same grassroots club, discussed the financial burden of repeatedly replacing children’s boots. A survey of 150 parents at Durham United Football Club confirmed that the problem was not only environmental. Families were struggling with the cost of equipment, while clubs were looking for additional sources of income [3]. The first Re:Play pilot therefore combined all three problems: players could donate their unwanted boots, with Durham United receiving £2 for every pair collected. One boot drive generated more than £300 for the club and collected hundreds of pairs [3]. Boots that still had useful life were cleaned and restored before being sold again at a lower price. It is a small-scale example of a principle increasingly discussed across the sports industry: the most sustainable product is often the one that does not need to be replaced. Football boots are particularly interesting in this regard because recycling them is not as straightforward as it might sound.

In 2026, researchers working with Northumbria University through the Arrow innovation programme analysed ten pairs of football boots supplied by Re:Play. Their conclusion was striking: because boots contain a complex combination of materials, there are currently no viable technologies capable of recycling them at scale [3][4]. Leather or synthetic uppers, rubber soles, plastics, adhesives, dyes and other components are assembled into a single product. Separating those materials at the end of its life can be difficult and expensive, this creates an important, and often not clear, distinction between recycling and reuse.

Recycling sounds like the obvious environmental solution because it allows materials to enter a new production cycle, but recycling is not automatically the best option. If a product can still perform its original function, keeping it in use may avoid the environmental impacts associated with producing an entirely new one in the first place. The research supporting Re:Play found precisely that extending the life of football boots through resale was the most effective near-term strategy for reducing their environmental impact [3][4].

That conclusion is consistent with the wider footwear industry, life-cycle studies have repeatedly shown that much of a shoe’s environmental impact is generated before it reaches the consumer, particularly during the manufacture of its components [5]. For footwear, therefore, simply throwing a product away after a relatively short period can mean discarding not only the physical object, but also all the energy and resources invested in producing it. Nevertheless, there is another problem too: consumer behaviour.

A 2025 study published in Oeconomica Jadertina (a scientific journal published by the Department of Economics at the University of Zadar) examined how football players think about the sustainability of their boots. Researchers surveyed players from two amateur football clubs in southern Germany and found that most participants did not prioritise environmental considerations when buying or disposing of football boots. Comfort, appearance and fit were generally more important, while the majority still disposed of unwanted boots in the general waste stream. There was, however, one encouraging finding: many players already extend the lifespan of their boots through care and prolonged use [6]. That may sound insignificant, but it points towards a potentially important shift in football culture. Circular economy does not necessarily need futuristic materials, sophisticated recycling plants or a completely redesigned football boot. Sometimes, it begins with something much more mundane: not throwing away something that still works.

Re:Play is now trying to scale that idea, its network works with grassroots clubs, schools, charities and organisations in the waste sector, while a pilot with Durham County Council has introduced football-boot collection points at household waste recycling centres [3].

Luckily the concept is not unique, other initiatives are exploring similar models across Britain. Utilita’s Football Rebooted campaign, for example, was launched with the ambition of keeping at least one million pairs of boots away from landfill, collecting unwanted footwear and making it available to people who need it. Universities and football organisations have also begun introducing collection schemes, while projects such as Boots Swap UK allow players to exchange unwanted boots for pre-loved pairs.

Football’s governing bodies are beginning to embrace the broader idea as well. UEFA’s circular economy guidelines promote a shift away from the traditional “take, make, consume and throw away” model towards a system based on four principles: reduce, reuse, recycle and repair [7].

Figure 1: Reduce, reuse, recycle and repair cycle explained. Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay.

For years, sustainability has often been presented as a question of what happens to products after we are finished with them. Can the plastic be recycled? Can the material be recovered? Can the waste be transformed into something else? But the story of Re:Play suggests that perhaps the first question should come earlier: Do we really need to get rid of it yet? A pair of football boots that lasts twice as long does not require a second manufacturing process simply to replace the first pair. A boot passed from one child to another can reduce waste while also making football more affordable, and a pair collected by a grassroots club can potentially generate revenue for the very community that keeps the game alive. That is what makes the County Durham experiment more than a story about old football boots.

It is a reminder that sustainability in sport does not always require changing the way the game is played. Sometimes, it means changing what happens to everything around it. The boots may eventually wear out, every product has an end point, but perhaps before that happens, they should be allowed a few more matches.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. [1] MSN. (n.d.). How this County Durham social enterprise is keeping football boots from landfill. https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/general/how-this-county-durham-social-enterprise-is-keeping-football-boots-from-landfill/ar-AA27BnGq
  2. [2] Replay Football. (n.d.). Sustainability. https://replayfootball.co.uk/pages/sustainability
  3. [3] Arrow Innovation. (n.d.). Quantifying environmental impact. https://arrowinnovation.org.uk/case-studies/quantifying-environmental-impact/
  4. [4] The Northern Echo. (2024, April 10). Durham start-up helping keep 13m football boots from landfill. https://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/26267236.durham-start-up-helping-keep-13m-football-boots-landfill/
  5. [5] Bodoga, A., Nistorac, A., Loghin, M. C., & Isopescu, D. (2024). Environmental impact of footwear using life cycle assessment—Case study of professional footwear. Sustainability, 16, 6094. https://doi.org/10.3390/su16146094
  6. [6] Ludin, D., Avdyli, F., Weiwadel, T., Mueller, E., & Wellbrock, W. (2026). Do football players act sustainably? An explorative study focusing on opportunities and limits of sustainable consumption and disposal of football boots. Oeconomica Jadertina, 15, 131–145. https://doi.org/10.15291/oec.4770
  7. [7] UEFA. (n.d.). Circular economy. https://www.uefa.com/sustainability/environment/circular-economy/

Cover and preview image: Pile of old sport boots. Phot by Sadiq Ali on Pexels.

The Environmental Cost of a Widespread World Cup

When the FIFA World Cup 2026 was awarded to Canada, Mexico and the United States, the tournament was presented as an opportunity to redefine sustainability standards for global sporting events. Hosting the competition across three countries was expected to reduce the need for new stadium construction by relying largely on existing infrastructure, while FIFA reiterated its commitment to climate action through emissions monitoring, renewable energy initiatives and carbon offsetting programmes.
Yet, as discussed recently in our article Beyond the Final Whistle , infrastructure represents only one piece of the environmental puzzle. Transport, particularly aviation, remains by far the largest contributor to the carbon footprint of international mega-events. The expansion of the tournament from 32 to 48 teams, together with 104 matches spread across 16 host cities separated by thousands of kilometres, has dramatically amplified this challenge. Several independent analyses now suggest that FIFA World Cup 2026 could become the highest carbon-intensive tournament in football history, with total emissions potentially exceeding nine million tonnes of CO₂ equivalent, largely driven by international and domestic flights [1; 2].

Among the many planes crossing North America during the tournament, one attracted particular attention, those of FIFA President Gianni Infantino. Often taking many viewers by surprise, as it was deemed not humanly possible, he travelled continuously between host cities, sometimes even attending two matches on the same day in two different and very distant places, using a private jet provided through FIFA’s partnership with Qatar Airways [1]. According to investigations led by journalists from BBC Sport, by the middle of the competition his itinerary had already exceeded 43,000 miles (approximately 69,000 kilometres), generating emissions that climate experts estimated to be comparable to the annual carbon footprint of dozens of average citizens [1]. From a strictly quantitative perspective, the emissions associated with one individual remain negligible compared with those produced by hundreds of thousands of supporters travelling across North America. However, limiting the discussion to absolute numbers misses a much broader issue, the significance of the FIFA President’s travel lies primarily in its symbolic and institutional value. Climate governance is in fact built not only on technological solutions but also on credibility.

Public institutions, governments and international organisations are increasingly expected to demonstrate consistency between their environmental commitments and the behaviour of their leaders. This principle, often referred to as carbon accountability, extends beyond measuring emissions, it concerns whether organisations are perceived as genuinely committed to reducing them. This distinction is particularly relevant for sport where, unlike industrial sectors, emissions are directly linked to production. Sporting events derive much of their environmental impact from choices about mobility, logistics and organisational priorities, and every decision, from the tournament format to travel schedules, reflects a governance model rather than a technological necessity. The contradiction therefore becomes evident, while FIFA has repeatedly identified aviation as one of the greatest sustainability challenges facing the World Cup [3], its own president relied extensively on one of the most carbon-intensive forms of transport available.

Private aviation especially occupies a unique position within climate science discussions, although it represents only a tiny fraction of global flights, emissions per passenger are several times higher than those associated with commercial aviation because aircraft frequently transport only a handful of passengers while consuming comparable amounts of fuel. The International Energy Agency and numerous academic studies have consistently identified private jets as among the least efficient modes of transport in terms of emissions per passenger kilometre [4]. The issue extends beyond climate accounting; it concerns the messages conveyed by institutional leadership. Major sporting organisations increasingly present themselves as actors within global sustainability agendas, FIFA itself has linked its environmental strategy to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals [5], while international federations routinely publish sustainability reports highlighting their commitment to decarbonisation, such commitments inevitably raise expectations regarding behavioural coherence.

This tension has fuelled growing accusations of high levels of greenwashing in international sport; the term describes situations in which ambitious environmental communication is not matched by equally ambitious operational changes.  Sustainability strategies that focus predominantly on carbon offsetting, without addressing the structural drivers of emissions, risk producing limited environmental benefits while reinforcing public scepticism [6]. The 2026 World Cup illustrates precisely this dilemma, using existing stadiums undoubtedly reduced emissions associated with construction. However, these savings are likely to be overshadowed by transport-related emissions generated by unprecedented geographical dispersion. In environmental assessment, avoiding emissions through infrastructure reuse cannot fully compensate for creating new emissions through increased aviation demand.

Figure 1: Illustration of the penalty area with green melting away, Image by Guilherme Gomes from Pixabay

The contradiction becomes even more complex when considered within the geopolitical context surrounding the tournament. Despite being hosted in North America, the competition has highlighted FIFA’s increasingly global political network. Qatar Airways, one of FIFA’s principal commercial partners, played a central logistical role throughout the tournament, including the provision of aircraft used by many senior officials [1]. At the same time, the organisation continues to maintain sponsorship agreements with major fossil fuel companies, most notably Saudi Aramco, despite mounting criticism from scientists and environmental organisations regarding the compatibility of such partnerships with global decarbonisation goals [2]. Beyond sponsorships, the tournament unfolded amid broader geopolitical tensions, like immigration restrictions, visa uncertainties affecting supporters from several countries and ongoing diplomatic disputes inevitably influenced participation and travel patterns. Football, once portrayed as politically neutral as every sport should be, increasingly reflects the complexities of an interconnected world where sport, diplomacy and international business are deeply linked together.

In this context, mobility is not simply a logistical issue but also a political one. Every flight carries an environmental cost while also reflecting broader choices about priorities, accessibility, and who is expected to bear responsibility for reducing emissions. Although supporters are often encouraged to lower their environmental impact through individual behavioural changes, institutional actors are in a far stronger position to shape a tournament’s overall emissions through the strategic decisions they make [1].

Scientific literature on mega-events [7,8] consistently reaches a similar conclusion: technological efficiency alone cannot deliver meaningful emissions reductions if overall demand for long-distance travel continues to increase. This phenomenon, commonly described as the “rebound effect“, explains why improvements in efficiency are frequently outweighed by growth in the scale of an activity. The expansion of the FIFA World Cup embodies this paradox, larger tournaments create greater economic opportunities, wider global audiences and increased commercial revenues. At the same time, they require more flights, longer travel distances and increasingly complex logistics, environmental sustainability therefore becomes less a question of engineering than of governance.

Ultimately, the controversy surrounding Gianni Infantino’s travel should not be interpreted simply as criticism directed at one individual. Rather, it exposes a broader challenge confronting international sport: can global sporting institutions credibly lead climate action while simultaneously expanding the scale and mobility demands of their flagship events? The answer will shape far more than the environmental legacy of the 2026 FIFA World Cup; it will determine whether sustainability in global sport evolves into a measurable transformation of organisational practice or remains primarily a powerful narrative accompanying business as usual.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. BBC Sport. (2026). Infantino’s World Cup travel under scrutiny. https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/cgev5wy0zg3o
  2. PRmoment. (2026). A FIFA World Cup far from net zero. https://www.prmoment.com/esg/a-fifa-world-cup-far-from-net-zero
  3. https://inside.fifa.com/sustainability/sustainability-strategies-for-events
  4. International Energy Agency. (2024). Aviation – Tracking Clean Energy Progress.
  5. United Nations. (2015). Transforming our world: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.
  6. NC State University. (2026). FIFA World Cup Faces Growing Sustainability Challenges, https://cnr.ncsu.edu/news/2026/06/fifa-world-cup-sustainability/
  7. Gogishvili, D., & Müller, M. (2025). Mega-events and the climate: what’s the game?. Current Issues in Sport Science. https://ciss-journal.org/article/view/12055
  8. Su, X. et al. (2025). Carbon emission and energy risk management in mega sporting events. Frontiers in Environmental Science. https://doi.org/10.3389/fenvs.2024.1513365

Beyond the Final Whistle

When FIFA awarded the organization of the 2026 football World Cup to the United States, Canada and Mexico, it did so with a clear objective: to deliver the most inclusive and spectacular tournament in history. With 48 national teams taking part, 104 matches and 16 host cities spread across three countries, the North American edition represents the biggest expansion the competition has ever seen until now [1]. Alongside the sporting enthusiasm, however, a question has emerged that is increasingly central to the organization of such mega-event, can it truly be environmentally sustainable? The issue clearly goes beyond football alone; in recent years, major international events (such as the recent Milan-Cortina Winter Olympics) have become a symbol of the contradictions of the ecological transition, on one hand they promote innovation, investment and environmental awareness; on the other, they entail enormous energy consumption, mass travel expenditures and significant greenhouse gas emissions. The 2026 World Cup sits squarely at the heart of this debate, which is heightened by the immense popularity of the world’s most-watched sport.

One of the factors that sets this edition apart from many of its predecessors concerns the infrastructure management. Unlike in South Africa in 2010, Brazil in 2014 or Qatar in 2022, no stadium has been built exclusively for the tournament. All matches are being played in existing venues, which have subsequently been upgraded to meet FIFA’s required standards [1]. From an environmental perspective, this is a particularly significant decision. Numerous studies on the life cycle of sports infrastructure show that the construction phase is one of the main sources of emissions associated with major events, particularly due to the use of concrete and steel, materials characterised by a high carbon footprint.

The use of existing facilities also reduces the risk of so-called white elephants, venues that, once the event is over, remain underused, generating economic and environmental costs for local communities. FIFA has accompanied this decision with a broader Sustainability and Human Rights Strategy, which involves host cities, national associations and commercial partners in shared objectives relating to energy, waste, responsible procurement and social inclusion [1].

Figure 1: Vancouver Stadium (Canada) with a football and the FIFA logo next to it, source [7]

However, sustainability also depends on the day-to-day management of sports facilities, and in this regard, several Mexican stadiums involved in the tournament have become interesting case studies for the adoption of innovative environmental technologies.

According to an in-depth report published by Wired [2], venues such as the Estadio Azteca in Mexico City, the Akron Stadium in Guadalajara and the BBVA Stadium in Monterrey have implemented high-efficiency LED lighting systems, smart energy consumption monitoring, rainwater harvesting and advanced waste sorting schemes [2]. Some of these venues have also introduced reusable cup schemes and strategies to reduce single-use plastic during events, following an increasingly widespread trend in the international sports sector [2]. Although these measures may appear minor, they can yield significant results. According to the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) [3], waste management is one of the areas in which sporting events can achieve the most rapid and measurable improvements in the short term.

Whilst the stadiums represent the most visible aspect of sustainability, the main environmental issue surrounding the 2026 World Cup lies elsewhere. According to an estimate compiled by the carbon accounting firm Greenly and reported by Reuters [4], the tournament could generate around 7.8 million tonnes of CO₂ equivalent, more than double the emissions attributed to the 2022 World Cup in Qatar [4], and the main cause is the geographical location of the event itself. The host cities are, in fact, spread across a vast territory stretching from western Canada to central Mexico. This means that teams, fans, journalists, sponsors and logistics operators will be forced to travel thousands of kilometres throughout the tournament, unfortunately air travel is currently the most difficult component to decarbonise within the transport sector. Even with efficient stadiums powered by renewable energy, flights continue to account for the lion’s share of the total emissions associated with an international sporting event. It is precisely for this reason that some researchers have described the North American World Cup as a crucial test to determine whether it is possible to reconcile the growing expansion of global sporting competitions with the climate targets set by the 2015 Paris Agreement [4].

As well as contributing to global emissions, the tournament will have to contend directly with the effects of climate change. Several climatologists have highlighted that some host cities may experience particularly high temperatures during the summer months, especially in the southern United States and the northern regions of Mexico [5]. Extreme heat poses a real threat not only to sporting performance but also to the health of fans, workers, volunteers and organising staff. To address this risk, FIFA has put in place specific protocols, including mandatory hydration breaks (which have been heavily criticised for the inclusion of adverts), continuous monitoring of weather conditions and emergency procedures in the event of particularly high temperatures [5]. In this sense, the 2026 World Cup is also taking on the role of a global testing ground for climate adaptation. The measures adopted could, in fact, become a model for other sporting competitions faced with an increasingly unstable climate [3].

However, the sustainability of a major event is not measured solely whilst it is taking place. The true assessment comes in the years that follow, when it is evaluated whether the investments and innovations introduced have generated lasting benefits, the famous ‘legacy’ of an event. FIFA itself recognises this principle in its official strategy, providing for monitoring and reporting activities that will continue even after the tournament has ended [1]. The aim is to transform the World Cup into a catalyst for existing urban projects, fostering permanent improvements in energy efficiency, resource management and sustainable mobility. The decision to use infrastructure that is already operational represents, from this perspective, a significant advantage. All the stadiums involved will, in fact, continue to be used by professional teams, for cultural events and community activities, thereby reducing the risk of waste and neglect. However, the most complex issue remains unresolved: how to offset the enormous climate impact generated by international travel. In recent years, many sports organisations have turned to emissions offset programmes using carbon credits [3]. However, the scientific community is increasingly emphasising that carbon offsetting cannot replace a genuine reduction in emissions at source. For this reason, many observers regard the 2026 World Cup as an important test case to assess whether the sports sector is capable of moving from a carbon-offsetting approach to one of genuine decarbonisation [3].

This event presents organisers and civil society with a complex reality. On one hand, we see more efficient stadiums, waste reduction programmes, climate strategies and a growing focus on sustainability in the governance of the event. On the other hand, there are critical issues relating to transport emissions and the increasing scale of global sporting competitions. For this reason, the tournament’s environmental success cannot be assessed solely by the number of certifications obtained or the initiatives implemented during the weeks of competition. The true measure of its impact will be its ability to leave a lasting legacy, with cities more resilient to climate change, more efficient infrastructure, replicable organisational practices and greater awareness of the relationship between sport and sustainability. Ultimately, the most important challenge of the 2026 World Cup is not about who will lift the trophy, but rather the ability of world football to demonstrate that even the biggest sporting event on the planet can contribute to the ecological transition rather than hinder it.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. FIFA (2025). FIFA World Cup 2026 Sustainability and Human Rights Strategy
  2. Wired (2025). How Mexican World Cup Stadiums Achieved FIFA’s Environmental Certifications. Wired Magazine.
  3. United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). Sports for Climate Action Framework. https://unfccc.int/climate-action/sectoral-engagement/sports-for-climate-action
  4. Reuters (2026a). Climate cost of expanded World Cup under scrutiny as emissions set to soar. https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/climate-cost-expanded-world-cup-under-scrutiny-emissions-set-soar-2026-06-09/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
  5. Reuters (2026b). Volatile summer weather threatens to turn World Cup into test of heat.
  6. https://www.pexels.com/it-it/foto/pallone-da-calcio-adidas-blu-arancione-nero-verde-bianco-sul-campo-verde-47354/
  7. https://www.pexels.com/it-it/foto/stadio-di-vancouver-e-pallone-gigante-della-fifa-38104078/

No Sport Without Nature

In the daily debate on the measures needed to combat global warming on our planet, sport and environmental protection are often seen as two parallel worlds. On the one hand, sport is associated with health, well-being, social interaction and performance. On the other hand, nature conservation depicts images of protected areas, ecological monitoring and environmental management policies. Yet these two fields are far more interconnected than one might think. This realisation has inspired researchers to develop a tool that aims at bringing these two worlds together: it is called BENCHES (acronym for Biodiversity, Ecosystems and Nature Conservation Helped and Enhanced by Sports), a European project funded by the Erasmus+ Sport programme that proposes an innovative vision: to transform the sports sector into an active player in biodiversity conservation [1]. It is coordinated by the Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna in Pisa and was launched in February 2024 [2]. It will run until January 2027, with a total budget of approximately €400,000 [2]. The main objective of the project is to study and measure the two-way relationship between sport and nature, analysing, on the one hand, the impacts that sporting activities, infrastructure and events have on ecosystems and, on the other, sport’s own dependence on ecosystem services, like the benefits provided by nature that make the practice of many sports possible [1].

Take, for example, trail running, which depends entirely on the quality of the trails and the stability of forest ecosystems, or sailing, which is made possible by the health of marine and coastal environments. Even seemingly ‘urban’ sports such as football are not entirely disconnected from the proper protection of natural resources. The management of stadiums, playing surfaces, water consumption, and event-related transport can have tangible, highly significant environmental consequences. 

BENCHES therefore stems from an observation that is as simple as it is often overlooked: sport is not environmentally neutral. The construction of facilities, land use, noise pollution, waste production, emissions from the transport of athletes and spectators, and habitat alteration are just some of the pressures exerted by the sports sector on biodiversity. However, precisely because of its enormous capacity to mobilise people, economic resources and media attention, sport can also become an extraordinary vehicle for cultural and operational change [3].  

The project involves several international partners representing various ecosystems and sporting disciplines. Partners include World Athletics, the International Biathlon Union, World Sailing, the Italian Canoe and Kayak Federation and the football club S.L. Benfica, as well as the sustainable communications agency Touchline [1]. This diversity of stakeholders enables the analysis of sports taking place in very different environmental contexts. Mountains and forests for biathlon and trail running, oceans and seas for sailing, rivers and lakes for canoeing and kayaking, and urban environments for football [1].

One of the most interesting outcomes of BENCHES has been the development of a digital biodiversity assessment tool [2] designed for sports organisations. National and international federations, clubs and event organisers will be able to measure their impact on ecosystems more systematically, identify critical issues and define mitigation strategies. This is an important step, because whilst many sports organisations have already begun addressing climate sustainability, such as reducing CO₂ emissions or improving energy efficiency, biodiversity often remains a secondary and less-measured issue. Alongside the digital tool [2], the project will also produce a handbook on Nature-Based Solutions, operational guidelines inspired by natural processes. This means, for example, promoting sports facilities designed to integrate better with ecosystems, green space management strategies that support pollinators and local species, or natural drainage systems to limit water consumption and soil erosion [1].

BENCHES’ approach is particularly significant from a cultural perspective as well. In recent years, the concept of sustainability in sport has broadened, moving beyond a focus solely on offsetting carbon emissions or eliminating single-use plastic from events. The real challenge lies in recognising that sports organisations are part of complex socio-ecological systems. A stadium, a ski slope or a regatta are not simply ‘events’, but activities set within living environments with delicate ecological balances.

Figure 1: Athlete during a trail running race in Romania. Photo by Alin Serban on Pexels.

The project also aligns perfectly with other international initiatives such as the Sports for Nature framework, promoted by UNEP, IUCN and the IOC [4], which calls on the sports sector to protect and restore nature. The added value of BENCHES, however, lies in its practical application, providing concrete tools, training and field-tested case studies. Another strategic aspect concerns raising public awareness. Sport possesses a unique narrative and symbolic power; millions of people follow competitions, identify with athletes and teams, and attend live events. Integrating environmental conservation messages and practices into this context means reaching audiences who would rarely be reached by traditional scientific communication channels. If an international federation introduces biodiversity criteria into its events, or a major football club communicates environmental protection initiatives, the message gains visibility and legitimacy. In other words, sport can act as a cultural multiplier for the ecological transition.

BENCHES highlights a paradigm shift: nature is no longer viewed merely as a ‘backdrop’ for sport, but as an ecological infrastructure upon which the very survival of many disciplines depends. Without snow, biathlon faces a crisis; without clean water, canoeing and sailing lose their functional habitat; without resilient green spaces, many outdoor activities become less viable. In an era marked by significant signs of decline in many natural components, such as habitat loss and the reduction of animal and plant biodiversity, this awareness is set to become central. The future of sport itself is not merely about reducing its carbon footprint, but about the ability to recognise and value the natural capital that makes it possible on a daily basis.

BENCHES is therefore much more than a European research project; it is an interdisciplinary laboratory that seeks to redefine the relationship between sporting performance, environmental governance and biodiversity conservation. If it succeeds in developing tools that sports organisations can actually adopt, it could become a model that can be replicated on an international scale. Protecting nature is not merely an ethical responsibility for sport, but a prerequisite for its very future.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna. (2024). Difesa della biodiversità e sport: La Scuola Sant’Anna coordinatrice del progetto triennale. https://www.santannapisa.it/it/news/difesa-della-biodiversita-e-sport-la-scuola-santanna-coordinatrice-del-progetto-triennale
  2. BENCHES Project. (n.d.). Biodiversity, ecosystems and nature conservation helped and enhanced by sports. https://erasmus-benches.com/
  3. World Athletics. (2022, 4 aprile). World Athletics joins BENCHES, a project to assess sport’s impact and dependency on nature. https://worldathletics.org/athletics-better-world/news/world-athletics-benches-project-sports-impact-on-nature
  4. Sports for Nature. (n.d.). World Rugby helps suppliers consider nature. https://sportsfornature.org/case-study/world-rugby-helps-suppliers-consider-nature/

When the snow disappears

The revenue generated by ski resorts reached an estimated record of 5 billion dollars in 2022 and is expected to reach 15.0 billion by 2032, an annual growth rate of 8% [1].

However, as evidenced by recent winter seasons of low and rare snowfall, global warming directly threatens the mountain environment and the future of skiing. In recent decades, rising global temperatures have led to an 86% decrease in snowpacks in April in the United States alone between 1955 and 2022 [1]. Furthermore, it is predicted that 53% of European ski areas will fall into the ‘very high risk’ category in terms of natural snow cover if the 2°C increase in global average temperatures, the upper limit set by the Paris Agreement, is reached [1].

To try and address these serious issues, the International Ski and Snowboard Federation (FIS) published a practical guide in December 2024 to help ski resorts around the world meet the challenges of climate change. Since they operate in natural environments that are extremely sensitive to rising temperatures it offers them a unique opportunity to be leaders in the ecological transition [2].

The Folgaria ski resort for example, one of the largest in Trentino with 70 km of slopes and 26 lifts, has over the years developed three artificial snowmaking reservoirs, necessary to cope with a prolonged absence of natural snow. The area well represents the current ambivalence of Alpine skiing: on the one hand it remains central to the winter tourism economy, on the other hand, it shows a strong dependence on energy-intensive and water-consuming technologies. The provincial strategy for sustainable development of Trentino (SproSS) [3], however, makes explicit reference to the urgency of rationalising water consumption and favouring mountain tourism models capable of coexisting with the growing scarcity of resources, favouring the multifunctionality of the territory and greater summer use.

Around the world, scientists and stakeholders are already addressing these challenges by using and implementing cutting-edge technologies, collaborating with experts from various fields, and taking a scientific approach to increasing resilience soon. The FIS guide lays the foundation for future action that could minimise the carbon footprint of ski infrastructure while supporting biodiversity and wildlife conservation. The fourteen proposed initiatives are briefly described below [1]:

  1. Reducing the energy consumption of ski lift systems: It is estimated that the operation of a ski lift system consumes the same amount of energy that powers 3.8 households per year. Some options to reduce this impact include the installation of solar panels (CO2 savings of up to 470 million tonnes per year), and optimising the speed of ski lifts (additional energy savings of 20% per year).
  2. Adoption of renewable energies: Shifting from fossil fuels to renewable energies is key to reducing carbon emissions. The savings achieved are substantial, as demonstrated by the Snow Space in Salzburg (Austria), which from the 2019/2020 season uses 100% green electricity, and has already eliminated 9,800 tonnes of CO2.
  3. Set a net-zero target by 2050: Quantify the carbon footprint to identify emissions hotspots. Furthermore, to reach net zero, one must offset non-zero emissions, i.e. remove from the atmosphere an amount of CO2 equivalent to that released by the same entity. Ski resorts will be able to invest in diversified offsetting projects, such as tree-planting campaigns.
  4. Adopt an effective slope management plan: one example is slope mapping, i.e. the scientific study of areas with documented high biodiversity presence to ensure that these areas are marked and protected. In addition, habitats already damaged by ski operations must be identified to implement an effective restoration plan. 
  5. Conservation of natural habitats: special attention must be paid to endangered animal species such as the capercaillie, black grouse, common toad, tree frog and Alpine newt, as well as rare plant species such as orchids and gentians.
  6. Encourage sustainable travel methods: a skier travelling by train could take a ski holiday every winter for the next four years to equal the carbon footprint of another skier flying just once. Currently, travel alone accounts for 57% of a resort’s total emissions.
  7. Introducing ‘snow farming’ practices: snow is collected from the slopes and stored in specialised warehouses or depots through thermal insulation, often with materials such as sawdust or wood shavings, preserving it during the warmer months. Snow farming thus reduces the demand for artificial snow and provides a solution for the shortage of natural snow, eliminating dependence on weather conditions. 
  8. Implementing new technologies for less water consumption: EU-funded projects are already working on the creation of a solar-powered snow cannon, but a prototype to be put on the market has not yet been developed. In the meantime, ski resorts will have to minimise the amount of artificial snowmaking, using weather forecasting and monitoring systems to optimise the timing and amount of snowmaking. 
  9. Adopt an effective waste management plan: Achieving net-zero for waste involves minimising, reusing and recovering waste materials, turning them into valuable resources and ensuring that no solid waste is sent to landfill during the year. It must be ensured that partners take appropriate measures to reduce the environmental impact of ski and snowboard equipment.
  10. Collaborate with key local stakeholders: assist skiers in preserving the mountain environment, while recognising that they are an integral part of the landscape together with farmers.
  11. More sustainable catering: focus efforts on reducing food waste and emissions, as well as conserving water resources.
  12. More sustainable accommodation: Improving the sustainability of accommodation requires the implementation of a comprehensive strategy that addresses architecture, energy efficiency, water conservation and waste management.
  13. Reducing the impact of large events: Events such as World Cup ski stages can bring significant economic benefits to the local community, but on the other hand, it is essential to recognise that such events can also have negative effects on the natural environment.
  14. Create your own roadmap: a roadmap detailing measures and activities to support sustainability, from short to long term.
Figure 1: Swiss skier at the World Cup Lauberhorn, Wengen, Switzerland. Image by Andreas from Pixabay.

The FIS also announced that it has signed a new partnership with the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO), which will collaborate with an international sports federation for the first time in its history. The WMO and its national meteorological and hydrological services will provide data and expertise as part of joint initiatives to raise awareness and promote meaningful changes in the management of ski facilities worldwide. “The climate crisis is much bigger than the FIS – or sport, for that matter: it is a real crossroads for humanity. It is true, however, that climate change is, in a nutshell, an existential threat to skiing and snowboarding“, these are the words of FIS President Johan Eliasch. In 2023/24 alone, the FIS organised 616 World Cup competitions in all disciplines, spread across 166 venues, twenty-six of which were cancelled for weather reasons. Eliasch then concludes “We would be remiss if we did not pursue every possible effort that is rooted in science and objective analysis. That is what we are trying to do and that is at the heart of this promising collaboration with the WMO” [2].

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Fédération Internationale de Ski. (2024). Sustainability guide for ski resorts. https://assets.fis-ski.com/f/252177/x/93a1eb34fa/sustainability_skiguide_final.pdf
  2. World Meteorological Organization. (n.d.). FIS and WMO partnership highlights harmful effects of climate change on winter sports and tourism. https://wmo.int/news/media-centre/fis-and-wmo-partnership-highlights-harmful-effects-of-climate-change-winter-sports-and-tourism
  3. Provincia Autonoma di Trento. (n.d.). Strategia provinciale per lo sviluppo sostenibile (SproSS). https://agenda2030.provincia.tn.it/Trentino-2030/Strategia-provinciale-SproSS

Is a Positive Legacy Really Possible?

What remains of a major sporting event after the last race has been run or the last match played? How can one justify the huge amount of money spent for the organisation of such events if the host city is left with debts, a negative social and landscape legacy and expensive and underused facilities?

Often what is expected immediately after an Olympics or World Cup is not only a sporting success, but the renewal of infrastructure and a strong boost to the economy, revitalising a nation. However, there is frequently a legacy, i.e., the material and immaterial legacy that remains on the ground following a major event [1], which is negative. This does not only consist in the failure to exploit the infrastructure after the event is over but in losing the full potential of the event itself [2]. The legacy that is left behind can indeed justify the expense for both the promoting body and the host nation or city [2]. The International Olympic Committee has formally included legacy in its statute since 2003, and FIFA (Fédération Internationale de Football Association) has also become increasingly concerned with using sport events for the economic and social development of a territory.

Conventionally, a legacy has been divided into tangible and intangible[3]. The former is the most obvious and easily understood, almost always connected to short-term economic impacts, although its various manifestations are varied, complex and interconnected. The second includes social, political, sporting, and human capital impacts, ranging from basic training provided to volunteers to highly specialised managerial skills. These are all forms of impact that can be achieved in an area solely through the organisation of a major sporting event, and which the mere investment of money does not achieve [3].

Italy will host the Winter Olympics in Milan-Cortina next year, and an important objective defined in the presentation dossier for the five-ring event was to leave a positive legacy for our country. Each work had to somehow bring a favourable social spin-off to the territories involved, not only in terms of supporting sport. To date, however, one can only imagine future benefits in the Olympic village in Milan, which will be transformed into a student residence, in the biathlon track in Anterselva, and the new stretch of railway in the Riga valley in South Tyrol [4]. All other infrastructures, however, risk becoming white elephants after the event. Here are those that, according to the experience of past editions, are most at risk of long-term non-use, mainly due to lack of public demand:

  • Bobsleigh, skeleton and luge tracks: very expensive facilities to build and maintain, requiring continuous refrigeration and technical maintenance. Moreover, very few people practise these sports outside of Olympic or professional contexts.
  • Nordic ski slopes and biathlon: although more ‘popular’ than bobsleigh, they require large areas, artificial snow, and equipment that is not easily accessible to the general public.
  • Ski jumping trampolines: only professional athletes can really use them, as this sport requires advanced technique, support facilities and qualified trainers. Ski jumping competitions are also infrequent; there are few annual events on the FIS (International Ski and Snowboard Federation) calendar compared to what would be needed to justify the existence of the facility.
Figure 1: Bobsleigh track abandoned after the 1984 Sarajevo Olympics. Photo by Peter Donko on Unsplash.

The historic ski jump trampoline in Predazzo (TN) in the heart of Val di Fiemme, already the scene of World Cup events and World Championships, has been selected as the official venue for the Olympic ski jumping competitions. To meet the requirements imposed by the International Federation, the existing infrastructure underwent a major renovation. Initially planned with a lower budget, the project underwent an economic adjustment that brought the total cost to 38 million euros, with an additional 8 million related to the updating of prices and materials [5]. In Predazzo, one of the Olympic villages will also be built to host the athletes. The Latemar pavilion will be demolished and rebuilt with a modern structure with 69 rooms and 132 beds [5]. The Olympics also brought with them secondary works, including [5]:

  • 300,000 € to improve the road system;
  • 290,000 € to upgrade public lighting;
  • 50,000 € for the aqueduct remote control system;
  • 130,000 € for additional lighting sections, distributed between Predazzo and neighbouring areas.

In the dossier Nevediversa 2025 [5], Legambiente criticised the use of such large investments in sports facilities subject to strong climate uncertainties and a post-Olympic future often marked by abandonment or obsolescence. The risk, according to the report, is that these works will be a difficult legacy for local communities to sustain, especially in the absence of a clear plan for their future use. Even the Olympic Village, although modern and functional, leaves open questions about its intended use once the lights of the Games have gone out. In the strategic document adopted by the Autonomous Province of Trento for sustainable development (SproSS) [6] it is stated that the sustainable future of Trentino must be based on careful land management, a reduction in emissions, the containment of land consumption and the promotion of sustainable tourism. Considering these objectives, the construction and/or modernisation of Olympic infrastructures, which by their nature are temporary and have a high impact, raises important questions regarding the actual need and future usefulness of the facility, the potential consumption of land and resources, but also consistency with sustainable mobility and intelligent energy management.

The Olympics will be an international showcase for Trentino and Predazzo in particular will be a focal point of the five-ring event, ready to welcome hundreds of athletes and spectators from all over the world. However, as the SproSS document itself reminds us, “Trentino can and must play in advance” [6], promoting transformative innovations for the territory, not simply adaptation works. The risk is that the Olympic event will become a missed opportunity to experiment with new models of sustainability, to the benefit only of immediate needs and visibility. Between enthusiasm and sporting spirit, the greatest challenge remains open: building a sustainable future for the mountains of Trentino and those who live there all year round.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. AR Architetti Roma.. Grandi eventi: Strategie di gestione sostenibile nel resto del mondo. Retrieved from https://www.ar-architettiroma.it/ar-archivio/archivio/120-ar-113-tematiche/457-grandi-eventi-strategie-di-gestione-sostenibile-nel-resto-del-mondo.html
  2. SDA Bocconi. Grandi eventi sportivi e legacy. Retrieved from https://www.sdabocconi.it/it/sda-bocconi-insight/idee-senza-tempo/sport/grandi-eventi-sportivi-e-legacy
  3. Holt, R., & Ruta, D. (2015). Routledge handbook of sport and legacy: Meeting the challenge of major sports events. Routledge.
  4. Italia Nostra Trento. Olimpiadi invernali Milano Cortina 2026. Retrieved from https://www.italianostra-trento.org/olimpiadi-invernali-milano-cortina-2026/
  5. Legambiente. (2021). Nevediversa 2025. Retrieved from https://www.legambiente.it/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Nevediversa-2025.pdf
  6. Provincia Autonoma di Trento. Strategia provinciale per lo sviluppo sostenibile (SproSS). https://agenda2030.provincia.tn.it/Trentino-2030/Strategia-provinciale-SproSS

Cover image: Ski-jumping trampoline abandoned after the 2006 Olympics near Cortina d’Ampezzo. Image by 4h4photography from Pixabay.

Tackling global warming

Climate change is significantly transforming our planet and the sports industry will not be immune, in fact it may suffer significant economic and competitive impacts. A recent report commissioned by World Rugby, the governing body of the oval-ball sport that organizes the Rugby World Cup every four years and other international competitions, analyzed the impact of a +2°C increase in global temperature on its events, highlighting some of the risks but also some of the opportunities to adapt and contribute to environmental sustainability [1].

World Rugby is already a signatory to the Sports for Nature Framework led by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD).

Sir Bill Beaumont, chairman of the federation, stated: “We believe rugby can play its part in fighting the drastic loss of biodiversity on our planet by showing leadership and empowering members of our global family to safeguard our natural environment” [2]. The voice of the athletes was instead heard through the words of former player and current Australian Senator David Pocock: “Climate change is no longer a future threat; it is already here. The choices the rugby world makes today will determine the future of the sport and its ability to inspire sustainable action globally” [1]. The report used the latest scientific research, contained in the one of the latest version of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report, to outline the climate context to which the rugby world will have to adapt in the short and medium term, presenting and focusing on the main impacts of climate change for ten representative rugby nations (Argentina, Australia, England, Fiji, France, India, Japan, New Zealand, South Africa, and the USA) from different climate regions [1].

Fig. 1: Rugby player in the field. Image by Pawel Grzegorz from Pixabay

Among the main risks is a substantial increase in heat waves and humidity. Six of the ten nations analysed in the report are experiencing an increase in days with temperatures above 35°C, which will make training and competitions increasingly difficult, if not impossible, and increase the risk of heat stroke for athletes, spectators and staff [1]. Another important challenge will be posed by droughts, as reduced water resources compromise the quality and maintenance of turf fields, leading to hard surfaces and more injuries [1]. Finally, the increased frequency of extreme weather events, such as tornadoes and flooding, will put infrastructures at serious risk and may even submerge entire stadiums in coastal areas and islands, requiring costly maintenance work [1].

Thirty per cent of the analyzed venues (one hundred and eleven in total) are located in cyclonic zones, which will be subject to a steady increase in their destructive activity. Groups of turf management experts from all over the world have already been consulted in various working groups and are unanimous on the need to adapt playing surfaces to the changing climatic conditions, especially for the hotter and/or wetter ones. World Rugby’s natural turf guidelines already provide useful guidance on best practices and recommended turf types according to climatic specificities. These are only the direct effects, but there will also be indirect ones, which will affect the economy and the image of rugby. Insurance, facility maintenance and materials will become increasingly expensive. The governance of World Rugby will also face significant pressure to reduce its carbon footprint and promote sustainable practices, it could be even necessary to change regulations and calendars to safeguard the well-being of players and spectators.

The report points out that while athletes and spectators can adapt with preventive measures (hydration, scheduling of matches at cooler times), the fields and infrastructure show lower levels of resilienceto these impacts. Investments in new technologies, heat-resistant grass varieties and sustainable infrastructure are key to mitigating the risks [1].

Recognizing the challenges and opportunities presented by global warming, in 2022 World Rugby adopted an ambitious Environmental Sustainability Plan 2030 to systemically integrate sustainability issues into its governance, organizing and supporting sustainable events and promoting environmental protection in its sport through education, and knowledge sharing. One of the final recommendations in the report is that all national and international rugby organizations should promote and support local climate change adaptation and mitigation measures. Initiatives such as Rugby for Nature [2], launched by rugby communities globally to safeguard the natural environment and biodiversity in and around rugby facilities, demonstrate how governing bodies and affiliated unions can support local initiatives with practical resources adapted to the realities of climate change and biodiversity loss. The international federation will use the findings of the report to support its long-term planning, including the organization of major events as the future Rugby World Cups, as it continues to work with its stakeholders to make the sport more resilient for the future ahead.

This article is part of the project “Quiz Ambientali per un Trentino Più Verde!” carried out by Econtrovertia APS and sponsored by Fondazione Cassa Rurale di Trento (Notice of Approval of December 20, 2024).

References

Click here to expand the references
[1] worldrugby.org. (2024, June 3). Rugby for Nature | World Rugby.https://www.world.rugby/organisation/sustainability/climate-change
[2] worldrugby.org. (n.d.). Global rugby family invited to join the ’Rugby for Nature’ squad to help tackle biodiversity loss as World Rugby marks Earth Day 2024 | World Rugby.https://www.world.rugby/news/922346/global-rugby-family-invited-to-join-the-rugby-for-nature-squad-to-help-tackle-biodiversity-loss-as-world-rugby-marks-earth-day-2024

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. worldrugby.org. (2024, June 3). Rugby for Nature | World Rugby. https://www.world.rugby/organisation/sustainability/climate-change

  2. worldrugby.org. (n.d.). Global rugby family invited to join the ’Rugby for Nature’ squad to help tackle biodiversity loss as World Rugby marks Earth Day 2024 | World Rugby. https://www.world.rugby/news/922346/global-rugby-family-invited-to-join-the-rugby-for-nature-squad-to-help-tackle-biodiversity-loss-as-world-rugby-marks-earth-day-2024

Cover image: Oval balls on turf. Image by Vlad Vasnetsov from Pixabay

Game, Set… Green!

The year that has just ended marked an important growth of the tennis movement in Italy, we are facing an effect close to one that turns a sport into a collective mania, leading even those who do not know the difference between a racket and a frying pan to improvise as experts in slice and volleys [1]. This is obviously due to the great successes of Jannik Sinner in the men’s singles and Jasmine Paolini in the women’s singles, but also thanks to the national team victories and the Olympic medals last summer of Lorenzo Musetti and the Paolini/Errani duo.

As in so many other sports, given the increasingglobal focus on environmental sustainability, the challenge of climate change in this discipline has also encouraged sports facilities and retailers to adopt more responsible practices, especially in managing one of its main elements, the balls. However, the question that is often asked is what happens to all the balls used during every international tournament? Every year, around 330 million tennis balls are produced worldwide, but 97% of them are no longer reusable and are either burnt in incinerators for energy recovery or disposed of in landfills, where they take around 400 years to biodegrade [2]. In the US alone, an estimated 125 million balls end up in landfills each year [2].

The iconic yellow and white spheres characteristic of the sport are essential to the game, but their management and replacement remain inadequate, relying largely on subjective assessments and arbitrary timing, this practice leads to their premature disposal, contributing to significant environmental waste [3]. The balls degrade due to repeated impacts and environmental exposures that alter their performance characteristics over time. Several publications have identified that the type of playing surface adopted (e.g. clay, grass or concrete courts), temperature and humidity levels can be influential variables in the degradation of their performance [4].

In modern tennis thousands of balls are used every tournament, as they are frequently changed after a certain number of games or at the request of the players, however, current techniques often lead to those still suitable for use beingdiscarded prematurely. Nevertheless, recently their recycling and reuse rates have increased; organizations such as AceCycle were founded with the aim of reducing the overall environmental footprint of tennis. This non-profit company developed a method to collect used tennis balls, reuse them for community programs or recycle the materials in any way possible [5], but despite their efforts, current data on the lifespan of tennis balls is insufficient for an efficient reduction of the overall environmental impact of tennis.

This is why the ITF (International Tennis Federation) was invited, together with manufacturers and several national federations, to set up a working group with the specific aim of increasing the ‘life’ of each ball. A laboratory in Roehampton (England), south-west London, a few kilometres from the “All England Lawn” Tennis Club, houses a series of robots testing balls and rackets, as well as a wind tunnel powered by an ancient computer, used to test the aerodynamics of the balls [6]. A prototype was shown during a recent BBC Sport report in which Jamie Capel-Davies, head of the ITF’s science and technology department, presented a model with a polymer outer shell with holes, as opposed to the normal fabric covering over the rubber core. The researchers involved in the design say that it is still a prototype and that there may be a better solution, but it shows how the ITF is trying to stimulate innovation in the industry and be proactive [6].

Capel-Davies also stated that there could be the possibility of adjusting the current rules on when and how often balls are changed during matches to try to extend the lifespan of existing balls. “We are looking at the possibility of using fewer tennis balls, changing the size of the order that some tournaments make in terms of tennis balls and looking at the frequency of ball changes during matches so that fewer balls are needed”, he explained. “The second thing is to try to extend the life of the tennis balls. For example, repressurizing them to prolong their life” [6].

At the moment during the Wimbledon (England) tournament, ball changes occur every seven or nine games depending on the set. But in some events, the change can be as high as eleven or thirteen, the variability often depending on the length of the exchanges that occur in a single game. The working group also intends to consult the players on these ideas in the future, but Capel-Davies hopes that the athletes will recognize the considerable impact they could have. “I think sport has a very important role to play in terms of sustainability. It can use its profile to try to encourage sustainability and set an example to others in this area. So we want to try to use this influence in the most positive way possible” [6].

Incentivizing the collection of used tennis balls from clubs, schools and public courts to divert them from landfills can give them a new life in extremely innovative ways. Whether it is renewing court surfaces, designing dog toys or using them in other creative ways, the ITF must become more committed to finding solutions that can contribute to the well-being of our planet, one ball at a time.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Avallone, A., & Avallone, A. (2024, November 20). Effetto Jannik Sinner: perché il tennis adesso è così popolare (e pop) – BUNS. BUNS – human, digital, unsocial. https://www.beunsocial.it/2024/insight/intrattenimento/effetto-jannik-sinner-perche-il-tennis-adesso-e-cosi-popolare-e-pop/
  2. Gadde, Nishant & Tallapragada, Dheeraj & Dey, Shreyan & Mehta, Laksh & Chahal, Jashan & Yu, Ning. (2024). An Open-Access Machine Learning Framework for Sustainable Tennis Ball Management: Optimizing Use and Reducing Environmental Impact for Tennis Stores and Clubs. 10.20944/preprints202410.0609.v1.
  3. Bower, P. (2018). The science behind tennis ball performance and degradation. Journal of Sports Engineering and Technology, 232(2),125-135.
  4. AceCycle. (n.d.). https://www.acecycle.org/
  5. Scott, L. (2024, June 28). Sustainable tennis balls being tested by International Tennis Federation. BBC Sport. https://www.bbc.com/sport/tennis/articles/cyr76p8kg64o

Cover image: Tennis balls on grass court. Image by davidkenny91 from Pixabay.

NFL Green

Continuing our journey related to the sports industry in the United States of America and their initiatives related to environmental sustainability, in this article we will talk about the NFL (National Football League), the most important and famous professional American football league in the world, born exactly 101 years ago. In 1922, the first embryonic league founded in 1920, APFA (American Professional Football Association), was renamed with the acronym still used today. Since then, formats and franchises have changed names and locations, one thing has never changed: American football remains the most watched and polarizing sport in the land of the stars and stripes [1].

The regular season and its final (called theSuper Bowl), represent one of the North American cultural icons, so much so that it has become over time one of the most important symbols of American-ness. Because of the very high television audience that follows the last game of the year (the 2024 game peaked at almost 124 million viewers), the event is highly coveted by commercial advertisers, who go so far as to pay, in the auction for advertising space before, during and after the game, figures as high as four million dollars for thirty seconds of commercials (equivalent to about 133,000 dollars per second). In the 2024 edition, a 30-second spot came to cost $7 million, it can be said without any doubt that the NFL is a major sports industry and extremely competitive economically.

The NFL has embraced environmental sustainability since the 1990s, both on and off the field, with several significant actions that the league has been undertaking for more than three decades now with its NFL Green programme. “The main goal of NFL Green is to reduce the environmental impact of our events and go above and beyond to leave a positive ‘green’ legacy in the communities that host our events”, NFL Green associate director Susan Groh told Food Tank [2]. However, this initiative is part of a broader commitment by the league to help protect the environment and improve the communities that host events. Let’s take a look at how it is articulated and what its main outcomes are [3].

Waste Management and Recycling

One of the main actions of NFL Green is the sustainable management of waste generated during events such as the Super Bowl, the Pro Bowl (football’s All-Star Game) and the Draft (when new players from college are chosen by franchises). This includes an extensive recycling system, which aims to minimize the number of materials sent to landfills. The first massive recycling initiative was launched in 1994, aimed at transitioning to a circular economy, to be implemented during games and related events. This then lasted until 2018 when it was replaced by the Rush2Recycle project [4] that helped to collect over 90% of the waste generated at Super Bowl LII (52), which was then composted, recycled and donated to several associations that care for the homeless and people in need. In addition, it engages in the recovery of materials such as sports equipment, clothes and furniture, which are donated to charities in local communities or reused for other events [3].

Reducing the Carbon Footprint

The NFL works with environmental organizations to offset the carbon emissions generated by the travel and operations required to organize its events. Part of this strategy is to fund reforestation projects or tree planting in host cities, helping to offset the environmental impact of transport and energy production. In fact, the NFL symbolically planted 57 trees in Arizona to honor Super Bowl LVII (number 57). The league has also completed six planting projects and has six more planned, for a total of more than 500 trees planted in Arizona alone before the grand final event [3].

Food Recovery

Another key point of the initiative concerns the reduction of food waste. During the events, unconsumed food is recovered and redistributed to food banks and local organizations, providing concrete help to people in need and reducing the environmental impact of food waste disposal [3].

Green Spaces and Community Projects

NFL Green also seeks to leave a positive and lasting impact on communities through the creation of green spaces. In partnership with local authorities, the league participates in the construction of parks and recreational areas in host cities, providing the community with ecologically sustainable infrastructure and spaces that benefit the well-being of residents [3].

Collaboration and Education

The NFL collaborates with various partners, including non-profit organizations and sponsors, to develop and implement sustainable practices. It also aims to raise awareness among fans and communities about the importance of sustainability, educating them on responsible and sustainable behavior both during events and in their daily lives [3].

In 2019, the NFL also joined the Green Sports Alliance, an organization that promotes environmental initiatives within the sports world. It includes more than 600 teams, leagues and individual arenas committed to reducing the amount of waste produced; conserving natural resources, including energy and water; and reducing the use of harmful chemicals, among other measures to increase sustainability. ‘The Green Sports Alliance is pleased that the NFL is joining our mission to support healthier, more sustainable communities where we live and play”, said Green Sports Alliance Executive Director Justin Zeulner. “Several NFL teams and venues have been members of our group for many years, and we are thrilled that the NFL, as a league, is making a formal commitment to the environment by joining the green sports movement and our impressive membership base”[5].

Fig 1: University Football Arena during a game. Photo by Foundry on Pixabay.

NFL Green is therefore not just a short-term initiative but represents an ongoing commitment to a more sustainable future in which the league strives to leave a positive legacy in the communities that host its major events. It also demonstrates how a major sports league can and should make a difference in combating climate change and protecting the environment, ultimately setting it as a model for the entire global sports industry.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Rigamonti, L. (2024, February 9). Cosa vuol dire l’acronimo NFL, scopriamone significato e storia del logo. DAZN. https://www.dazn.com/it-IT/news/football-americano/cosa-vuol-dire-lacronimo-nfl-scopriamone-significato-e-storia-del-logo/y2yeyxl2afzz15sc1h6ptx3fe
  2. MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference Speaker | Susan Groh. (n.d.). https://www.sloansportsconference.com/people/susan-groh
  3. NFL.com | Official Site of the National Football League. (n.d.). NFL.com. https://www.nfl.com/causes/nfl-green/
  4. From Sketch to Super Bowl: Rush 2 Recycle – Minneapolis Strategic Brand Design Agency | CAPSULE | Brand Research, Strategy and Design. (2018, February 19). CAPSULE. https://capsule.us/thoughts/from-sketch-to-super-bowl-rush-2-recycle
  5. Sunnucks, M. (2018, June 19). NFL Becomes Latest Pro League To Join Green Sports Alliance. Sports Business Journal. https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Daily/Issues/2018/06/19/Leagues-and-Governing-Bodies/NFL-Green.aspx

NHL Green

In my previous article, I analyzed the strategies to reduce the environmental impact that the National Basketball Association (NBA) has been pursuing within its organization in recent years. However, other professional leagues in the United States of America have the same, if not greater, importance on both an economic and competitive level. One of these is the NHL (National Hockey League), widely recognized as the world’s most important ice hockey league, founded in Montréal-Quebec in 1917 [1].

The league succeeded the National Hockey Association (NHA), which included only eleven Canadian teams, where ice hockey is the national sport and where the league was founded. Currently, after undergoing a major expansion phase, it includes 31 franchises, including seven in Canada and 24 in the United States. The regular season runs from October to April and each team plays 82 games [1], the same as in the NBA. Teams compete annually for the Stanley Cup, the oldest professional sports trophy in North America; the International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) itself considers it one of the “most important championships available to the sport” [2].

Ice hockey is an integral part of the culture and identity of Canada and also of many U.S. States; some famous players have often claimed to have honed their skills playing on frozen ponds, rivers, and lakes that are not lacking in the northernmost parts of the North American continent.

Unfortunately, the dramatic change in climate in these areas has led to winters with much warmer average temperatures, which have had asignificant impact on outdoor field hockey seasons. In recent years, a strong El Nino (a periodic climatic phenomenon that causes strong warming of surface waters in the South Central and Eastern Pacific Ocean) has brought warmer and drier conditions, as a result, there is now more awareness than ever of possible future complications for a sport that needs long periods with subzero temperatures posed by warm winter temperatures due to global warming [3].

As noted in the article “NBA Green”, the sports industry can have a significant influence on the protection of Earth’s natural resources. Therefore, the need for a significant change in corporate strategies regarding environmental sustainability has not gone unnoticed by sports organizations, mainly in the sports leagues in the United States and Europe, which are also the ones that generate the most revenue [4].

That is why in 2010 the NHL launched its own initiative, called “NHL Green”, to promote sustainable business and sports practices and also educate fans and raise awareness of environmental issues in their communities. NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman said at the time: “The game was born on frozen ponds, most of our players learned to skate on outdoor rinks. For this magnificent tradition to continue into future generations, we need the right winter weather, and as a league, we are in a unique position to promote this message”[3]. Thus, since 2010, the NHL has been tracking its environmental sustainability achievements and proudly shares this information with the public each year, including using the framework established by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s) to assess its environmental, social and governance (ESG) efforts [3].

In particular, they focused on goal number 6 of the SDG’s: “Ensure the availability and sustainable management of water and sanitation for all” [5].

Professional ice hockey necessarily needs large amounts of water, but the process of creating and resurfacing ice for the artificial rinks in the arenas is one of the most water-intensive operations of any sport in the world. On average, it takes 12,000 to 15,000 gallons of water (45 to 57 thousands of liters) to create an NHL regulation ice sheet, which is then usually kept frozen for an entire season. Once created, the employees of the arena then must scrape or shave the ice and rebuild it with an additional thin layer of water to ensure that the surface is optimal for the competitive play that takes place there [3].

Fig 1: Ice hockey game in the Calgary Flames’ Stadium. Photo by oskaline on Pixabay.

The main uses of water in NHL arenas include ice production, but it is also needed for cooling towers (used to reduce water temperature for reuse), food services, indoor plumbing, and even outdoor landscaping in some of the arenas. Together these uses represent a consumption of about 320 million gallons of water (nearly 1 billion liters), equivalent to about 500 Olympic-size swimming pools, that are used throughout the league during a single season [3].

However, NHL franchises are aware of their consumption and at the forefront of showing technological innovations to reduce their annual consumption. At Climate Pledge Arena, home of the Seattle Kraken, rainwater is captured from its roof, enough to fill a 15,000-gallon cistern to hold water to be used for ice-making. At Staples Center, home of the L.A. Kings, the arena uses an advanced environmental management system that helps capture water from the air, which is then stored in water tanks to be used for non-potable uses. Over the past 10 years, the NHL has also made a commitment to ensure a more sustainable water management of their arenas for the communities where they live and play. The league has offset over 88 million gallons of water through the purchase of water restoration credits in collaboration with partner Bonneville Environmental Foundation (BEF) [3].

The league’s commitment to water stewardship has positively inspired the hockey community at large with many other sustainable actions. One example is the use of broken-field hockey sticks to create artificial reefs and habitats for oysters (Rink2Reef project) [6].

The league has also commissioned future climate analyses of possible winter temperatures in Toronto Montreal and other locations home to NHL franchises by the end of this century, what these models show is a significant decline in days with subzero temperatures. The world’s premier field hockey league is certainly helping to reduce its environmental impact, but I want to conclude with these two questions: will there be any outdoor field hockey rinks in the future that are not artificially refrigerated? Will young people who want to take up this magnificent sport still be able to practice, like the champions of the past, in the lake or river near their homes? All teams seem committed to making this possible, even if much room for improvement still remains.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. NHL. (n.d.). A brief history of the NHL | NHL.com. https://www.nhl.com/history/a-brief-history-of-the-league
  2. IIHF – home. (n.d.). IIHF International Ice Hockey Federation. https://www.iihf.com/
  3. NHL. (2024, April 8). Official site of the National Hockey League | NHL.com. https://www.nhl.com/community/nhl-green/
  4. Trendafilova S, Babiak K, Heinze K (2013) Corporate social responsibility and environmental sustainability: Why professional sport is greening the playing field. Sport Management Review, 16(3), 298-313.
  5. Uno. (2019, March 14). Obiettivo 6: Garantire a tutti la disponibilità e la gestione sostenibile dell’acqua e delle strutture igienico-sanitarie. ONU Italia. https://unric.org/it/obiettivo-6-garantire-a-tutti-la-disponibilita-e-la-gestione-sostenibile-dellacqua-e-delle-strutture-igienico-sanitarie/?__cf_chl_tk=iAnTsnBFckeDsON4hyVkEWgHMeWs2mvpQuph.HUyI2s-1725621678-0.0.1.1-6036
  6. Home | rink2reef. (n.d.). Rink2reef. https://www.rink2reef.com/

NBA Green

The concept of sustainability is now recurring in the media world; from being a term unknown to most, it has become an inescapable element in the action (and communication) of all kinds of companies, so much so that by now it has almost fallen into the trivial or even to being no longer credible in certain contexts. Often, however, people are not clear about the origin of this term. First used back in 1992, during the first UN Conference
on Environment and Development held in Rio de Janeiro, sustainability is defined in environmental and economic sciences as “the ability to meet the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” [1].

Our planet’s resources must be used responsibly and equitably while preserving natural systems and biodiversity in the long term. However, the concept of sustainability has gained increasing attention from business and the sports industry, the wealthy sports leagues of the United States of America especially are leading the way in the green transition in this field [2].

The NBA(National Basketball Association) has demonstrated a strong commitment to environmental sustainability through the “NBA Green” initiative. This program aims to: “reduce the environmental impact of the league’s operations and its teams by promoting sustainable practices and increasing awareness of environmental issues” [4]. Below are some of the results achieved in the 2022-2023 season:

  1. Greenhouse gas emissions assessment: The NBA completed an initial greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions assessment for all NBA offices and league-operated events. This assessment is critical to understanding environmental impacts and planning for further reductions.
  2. Leadership in sustainability: 62% of NBA arenas now have “sustainability leaders,” with 14% of these individuals dedicated solely to promoting sustainable practices. This significant increase underscores the importance of sustainability within league facilities.
  3. Reduction in flight miles: During the 2022-2023 season, NBA teams reduced flight miles by 11%, improving player health and reducing greenhouse gas emissions from team travel by 39%.
  4. Climate Change Discussions: The NBA hosted its first workshop at a conference to discuss the effects of climate change and environmental injustices in sports. This event helped raise awareness and promote concrete action against climate change.
  5. Food Recovery and Donation: During the 2023 NBA All-Star Game, 4,000 pounds of food were recovered, providing approximately 3,400 meals to local community organizations and preventing 1.16 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions from food waste.

The third item listed above surely represents one of the most significant environmental problems facing the whole sports industry, including the NBA. This problem refers to the carbon emissions produced by team travel. During the regular season (excluding the playoffs), each of the 30 teams in the league plays a total of 82 games, with 41 being away games.

It goes without saying that in a country the size of the United States, 9,834,000 km² in area (the third largest nation in the world by surface area), this level of travel generates a significant amount of carbon emissions and other environmental impacts, contributing to climate change. In the 2018-2019 season, the NBA was the most polluting of the four major U.S. sports leagues (NFL, NHL, MLB) in terms of travel, with each team having to travel thousands of miles to play games [2]. However, U.S. sports organizations have begun to take serious steps to address this problem, such as investing in renewable energy and offsetting their carbon emissions through various types of actions. One such action, for example, has been to make changes to the schedule, reducing the hours and number of air travel required [2]. Some franchises are in fact based in the same city, the Lakers and the Clippers (Los Angeles) the Knicks and the Nets (New York), or at least in the same state within a short distance of each other, such as the Heat and the Magic (Miami-Orlando, Florida). So instead of playing against these teams weeks or months apart, there is a tendency for opponents to stay in the same city for several days, playing two away games consecutively and avoiding having to return to the same place several times.

Moreover, it’s important to emphasize that a scientist, Dr. Allen Hershkowitz, is leading the league’s overall sustainability strategy, not just any marketing manager. He sees the NBA as a platform to reach a wider audience than just the scientific community [4]. According to his study, “less than 20% of adults in the United States say they follow science news and updates regarding climate change, while more than 80% follow sports in its various disciplines” [4].

The NBA aims to be not only a beacon of innovation and entertainment in the sports world but also wants to establish itself as a leader in environmental sustainability. Through initiatives such as “NBA Green“, the league demonstrates that it is possible to reconcile top-notch sports performance and entertainment with a concrete commitment to protecting the planet and its natural resources. In an era when the term sustainability is often used out of hand, the NBA sets out to chart a course that other sports organizations can follow and emulate, to breathe new life into a concept that has become constantly overblown.

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Sostenibilità – Enciclopedia – Treccani. (n.d.). Treccani. https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/sostenibilita/
  2. Green, B. (2023, May 12). Sustainability & the NBA. Bethesda Green. https://bethesdagreen.org/sustainability-the-nba/
  3. Social Impact Report – NBA cares. (n.d.). NBA Cares. https://cares.nba.com/social-impact/
  4. Cooper, J. (2024, April 25). Hoop Dreams: the NBA and sustainability. Earth Day. https://www.earthday.org/hoop-dreams-the-nba-and-sustainability/
  5. Bailey Colon, for NBA.com. (2023, April 22). NBA Green: Dr. Allen Hershkowitz leads sustainability efforts around the league. NBA.com. https://www.nba.com/news/nba-green-dr-allen-hershkowitz-leads-sustainability-efforts-around-the-league

En Route To Sustainability

Having the ocean as its playing field, sailing has always had a close connection with nature and the marine environment. Only in recent years, however, have teams, events and organizations in the sailing industry begun to address the environmental impact their sport can cause [1]. The sustainability principles developed in this field are essentially based on three pivotal principles: using renewable energy sources for vessel production and navigation, reducing marine pollution, and respecting aquatic biodiversity [2]. Fortunately, adopting sustainable sailing practices is not difficult, especially since sailboats are powered most of the time by one renewable source, wind.

World Sailing, the governing body of the sport of sailing recognized by the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and the International Paralympic Committee (IPC), is considered a leading international federation in sustainability [3]. Due to the very environment in which the sport is practised, sailors are already concerned about nature conservation, and the federation has already implemented strategies to reduce its impact on the marine environment.

With the growing worldwide awareness of environmental issues and the urgency to mitigate negative impacts on the planet, to define a global strategy in this regard World Sailing first established a Commission on Sustainability, composed of experts from within and outside the sport.  The result of this initial work was the production of a document, the 2030 Agenda, an ambitious plan that aims to integrate sustainable practices into all areas of the sport [1].

The 2030 Sustainability Agenda

In this dossier, produced in 2016 and adapted in subsequent years, a detailed plan is laid out that aligns the operations of the sailing world with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the sustainability strategies of the International Olympic Committee (IOC). This document aims to transform sailing into an activity that respects the environment and actively contributes to its protection and improvement.

The Agenda is structured around several operational areas,  containing specific recommendations with key goals and deadlines. These, include technical standards, events, training, venues and facilities, membership and participation [4]. Some of the key objectives are:

  1. Create a framework for measuring and improving the life cycle of vessels. For example, it is expected that by 2028, 90% of materials used in Olympic boats will be recyclable or reusable.
  2. Reduce the use of single-use plastics and improve water quality at the race hosting venues. A key goal was to abolish the use of single-use plastic in World Sailing-organized events by 2019 and encourage this practice in domestic events by 2030, as well.
  3. Integrate sustainability into sailing teaching programs by raising awareness and promoting best practices among members and stakeholders.
  4. Implement effective strategies to reduce carbon emissions in line with the goals of the Paris Agreement (2015) on climate change.

To achieve these ambitious goals, the Federation has collaborated and is actively working with various partners to fund research and develop programs that promote sustainability. This collaborative approach is key to maximizing resources and ensuring that best practices are adopted globally [4]. Indeed, sailing is increasingly seen as a leader in sustainability in the world of sport: organizations such as The Ocean Race (a race between boats around the world, held every three to four years), SailGP (an international sailing competition featuring catamarans), and Sustainable Marine Alliance (an association created to promote the integration of sustainability into the marine industry to accelerate the transition to a healthier ocean) are all committed to promoting ocean health and broader climate action, often in collaboration with each other [1].

Fig. 1: Athletes preparing for a competition. Free-source picture by Dieter Ludwig Scharnagl downloaded from Pixabay.

Implementing such an ambitious agenda has presented and will certainly present difficult challenges, but the potential benefits could be significant. Promoting sustainability in sailing not only protects marine ecosystems but also creates a positive example for other sports industries and local communities. In addition, a commitment to protecting our planet can increase the sport’s popularity by attracting new participants and supporters who are sensitive to environmental issues.

World Sailing is demonstrating how sport can be a powerful vehicle for positive change. Through the 2030 Sustainability Agenda, sailing is not only a sport that harnesses the forces of nature but also becomes an active guardian of the marine environment. This commitment to environmental sustainability is a critical step toward a future where sport and nature coexist in harmony, inspiring millions of people around the world to protect and love our seas and oceans.

References

Click here to expand the references

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Bhatti, A. (2024, March 4). Sustainable Sailing: How to Conserve the environment While Sailing — Sea Going Green. Sea Going Green. https://www.seagoinggreen.org/blog/2023/07/21/sustainable-sailing-how-to-conserve-the-environment-while-sailing#:~:text=Sailing%20sustainably%20essentially%20revolves%20around,are%20powered%20by%20the%20wind
  2. Sustainability. (n.d.). https://www.sailing.org/inside-world-sailing/sustainability/
  3. Agenda 2030. (n.d.). https://www.sailing.org/inside-world-sailing/sustainability/agenda-2030-2/

The Olympic Forest Project

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) has long focused on the need to promote environmental sustainability within the Olympic movement. One of the main ways it is pursuing this goal is through the Olympic Forest project, an initiative aimed at offsetting the carbon emissions generated by the Olympic Games through the reforestation of degraded areas worldwide [1].

The concept is simple but can and will have a powerful impact. In fact, for every ton of carbon emitted during theOlympic Games (both winter and summer), a certain number of trees are planted [1]. These not only absorb considerable amounts of carbon from the atmosphere but also contribute to the creation of habitats for wildlife, soil conservation and the protection of water resources.

“Tackling climate change and preserving the environment are among everyone’s main responsibilities”, said Marie Sallois, IOC Director for Corporate and Sustainable Development. “As the Olympic movement, we want to contribute to the fight against climate change in our area of influence” [2]. Olympic forest network projects will not be limited to planting new trees, but may also include protecting or restoring existing forests, wildlife corridors, watersheds, and coastal ecosystems.

The aim of the Olympic Forest project is not only to offset carbon emissions but also to create a positive environmental legacy that will last over time [1]. Areas designated for reforestation are often selected based on the need to restore and protect natural ecosystems that have been compromised by deforestation, fire or other human activities.

In 2021, an initiative was funded to grow 590,000 native trees in some 90 villages in Mali and Senegal, the site of the Dakar 2026 Youth Olympic Games [1]. Olympic Forest aims to reach the people directly and improve their livelihoods and resilience. The project aims to create social, economic, and environmental benefits for communities in Mali and Senegal that are heavily affected by global warming despite being among the last places for climate-altering emissions. Increasing droughts and floods in these countries are leading to a constant degradation of land and food sources, putting enormous pressure on the populations of these nations.

To avoid problems encountered in some tree planting initiatives that have fallen victim to poor planning, choosing tree species that can withstand and grow even in places with extreme climates (such as the Sahel areas) is particularly important. This is why the IOC has chosen Tree Aid, a non-governmental organization (NGO), as a partner, which has implemented a rigorous tree selection process that takes into account both the economic needs of the community and environmental factors. This selection uses a bottom-up participatory approach that involves local community members in identifying suitable land, selecting tree species and agreeing on how the land will be managed to benefit the community and the environment [1].

However, this is only one element of the Olympic Committee’s overall commitment to environmental sustainability. For years now, a series of guidelines and criteria have been adopted to guide Olympic Games organizers in integrating sustainability into all aspects of event planning and execution in line with the directives of the Paris Agreement (2015) and the reduction of the organization’s footprint [3].

Fig. 1: Forest. Free-source picture by Brian Garrity downloaded from Pixabay.

Key sustainability guidelines include [3]:

  • Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Games organizers are encouraged to take measures to minimize greenhouse gas emissions during the preparation and conduct of events.
  • Responsible Resource Management: This includes the efficient use of water, energy and other resources during the Games, as well as the reduction of waste through recycling and other sustainable practices.
  • Promotion of Sustainable Mobility: Organizers are encouraged to promote public transport, cycling and other forms of low-emission transport during the Games.
  • Promotion of Biodiversity and Habitat Conservation: The IOC encourages the conservation and restoration of natural habitats and the protection of biodiversity in Olympic host areas.
  • Local Community Involvement:Organizers are encouraged to actively involve local communities in decisions and initiatives related to the Olympic Games, ensuring that the event has a positive social and economic impact.

The Olympic Forest project and the IOC Sustainability Guidelines represent a concrete commitment to reduce the environmental impact of the Olympic Games and promote sustainable practices globally. Through these efforts, the organizers of the Games are demonstrating their commitment to a more sustainable future with lower human impacts in the world of sport.

References

Click here to expand the references
[1] Olympic Forest. (n.d.). https://olympics.com/ioc/olympic-forest

[2] Olympic Movement steps up climate action, announces network of Olympic Forests. (2022, September 9). Olympics.com. https://olympics.com/ioc/news/olympic-movement-steps-up-climate-action-announces-network-of-olympic-forests

[3] The IOC’s climate commitment. (n.d.). https://olympics.com/ioc/sustainability/climate

References

Click here to expand the references
  1. Olympic Forest. (n.d.). https://olympics.com/ioc/olympic-forest
  2. Olympic Movement steps up climate action, announces network of Olympic Forests. (2022, September 9). Olympics.com. https://olympics.com/ioc/news/olympic-movement-steps-up-climate-action-announces-network-of-olympic-forests
  3. The IOC’s climate commitment. (n.d.). https://olympics.com/ioc/sustainability/climate

Football World Cup and Massive Events’ Environmental Effects

“In 2030, three continents – Africa, Europe and South America – and six countries – Argentina, Morrocco, Paraguay, Portugal, Spain, and Uruguay – will welcome and unite the world while celebrating together the beautiful game, and the centenary of the World’s Cup” [1].

With these words, FIFA announced how the World Championship for 2030 is planned to be held. 6 countries, 3 different continents, they affirm. On the other hand, they also maintain that this World’s Cup will be the “first neutral carbon emissions world’s event”. These two ideas do not seem to be compatible. Have you ever wondered what implies these kinds of events? Let’s take a quick look at it.

Hosting a World event in just one country is already a handful. First and most obvious, at least one stadium is needed. Some countries may already have stadiums with the required characteristics, but some others have to build them from scratch. Let’s skip for the moment the hydric consumption, just thinking about materials transportation and the building process, emissions-free?

Forgetting the stadium, let’s just take a look at the competition. There will be national teams from lots of countries that will have to move around in planes (private, of course). Each of the 48 national teams will play several matches [2]. Again, emissions-free?

And last, the most important thing in football is the fans. They are not staying at home, people would love to go and cheer for their teams [3]. In their case, the flights would probably be commercial, but the question remains, emissions free?

There were already some humanitarian doubts regarding the last world championship that have been talked about. If we only focus on the environmental part, it seems obvious that organizing an event with these proportions and characteristics while maintaining it at a zero-emissions level would be titanic. Even without flights, or buildings, what about the hydric impact? The grass of a football field needs to be daily watered, and it needs about 20000L of water each day per stadium [4]. Now, have we to multiply this value by at least six?

Once more, the criticism is not toward the event or football itself. It is toward a system that intends for events to be bigger, more massified … More profitable.

Because preparing for the World’s Cup just in one country is “too small” nowadays.
However, would it be that bad? Football started as a part of popular culture, and it is used to transmit values. They may not be the most sustainable or friendly – in this case, environmentally – now, but they could come to be. Consider the impact that the national teams could have taken a commercial flight, or even a bus or a train instead of a private plane. Not only the picture itself would be positive, and fans could take some examples, but if the team is taking those transports, it would mean that there have been some previous measures taken such as improvement of train infrastructure and other public transport services.

Ultimately, we need to rethink, just like so many other things, how our leisure model works if we want it to be compatible with a healthy planet and nature. we know it’s possible to change this kind of massive events such as football matches or concerts.

Coldplay took a 6-year-long break in which they tried to re-design their concerns and their tour to make them as sustainable as possible. After their last tour, they managed to drop their emissions by up to 50% [5]. And they can do more, they said.

A 6-year-long break is not a realistic thought for the football world, but we should give thought to re-designing how to make things, it seems more feasible. It is urgent to stop having as a goal to create the biggest and most impactful event, because even though some organizations like to think that impact – in the public’s eyes – is the most important, they tend to forget other impacts: environmental or social.

The (Un)Sustainable Sport

So many aspects of our lives can have a more or less negative impact on the environment. Usually, however, sports are not considered one of them. What could be wrong with wanting to be outdoors and in contact with nature? Perhaps our enthusiasm for the activities we practice leads us to gloss over the negatives, which we need to be aware of instead.

The Travel

A recent article [1] tries to bring attention to the component of travel with respect to our sports activities: if in order to do our bike tour we have to take a plane to California, surely the travel will be the largest component of our carbon footprint. In a similar way, the increasingly dry winters we are experiencing are “forcing” the winter sports enthusiasts to move more and more to find the best snow. Travel, however, is not the only component to consider if we are to weigh the impact of our activities.

The Facilities

Another fundamental aspect is to consider the facilities we need to practice it. Looking at winter sports, an example is cross country skiing, which trivially will be less impactful than alpine skiing because it does not require energy-intensive facilities such as ski lifts and slopes covered by artificial snow.
The issue of the environmental impact and cost-benefit discussion of facilities sports is very timely, especially looking ahead to the upcoming Winter Olympics in 2026 to be held in Italy. It has happened before that for Olympics cathedrals have been built in the desert: exaggerated facilities that remain systematically unused after the event and fall into neglect. An example of this are the facilities built for the 2006 Winter Olympics in Turin, with facilities that remained abandoned after a short time [2]. Also those of the 2004 Summer Olympics in Athens are not a good example, with massive stadiums and swimming pools that have become a symbol of modern reckless overbuilding [3].

Fig. 1: 2004 Athens Olympic Softball Stadium – shown abandoned in November 2018. Photo by Evanonthegc from Wikimedia Commons.

For the upcoming Milan-Cortina 2026 Winter Olympics we are in a similar situation, where for example, environmentalists have fought to stop the resurfacing of the Bobsled track in Cortina, proposing instead the one in Innsbruck, which is already usable. Unfortunately, the decision has been made and more than 85 million euros will be spent by the state (and thus by us taxpayers) on the new facility [4].

Fig. 2: Cesana Torinese – Pariol bobsled track, site of the bobsled, luge and skeleton competitions of the 20th Winter Olympics of 2006. It has been unused since 2011. Photo by Bumba from Wikimedia Commons.

The Materials and Equipments

A final aspect that we can consider, trying to understand the environmental impact of a sport, is the required equipment. If we compare sports such as running, where all you need is a pair of shoes and some clothes to practice it, to the formula 1 obviously there is no story. But there are less obvious factors to consider. Instead of running we might think of hiking, where we would need clothing to protect us from the elements, probably made in GoreTex. Unfortunately, the waterproofing of these fabrics is provided by perfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), which are highly polluting and also called “the forever chemical” because of their long half-life [5]. Currently, neither Patagonia, a famous environmentally conscious sportswear brand, is managing to go without PFASs, but has set a goal to stop using them from 2024 [6]. Finally, a recent investigation by Le Monde has raised the issue related to these pollutants, which you can see that are widely spread in waterways throughout Europe via the interactive map available on their website [7].

Physical activity gives many benefits to our lives, but that is not a reason why the world of sports should not take on its responsibilities. Understand that if even a simple waterproof jacket causes such significant damage to the environment, the awareness and the right information are indispensable to deal with modern advertising slogans, enabling us to make decisions that reflect our environmental awareness.

Telegram: @greenmarked
LinkedIn: @greenmarked
Instagram: @greenmarked.it

Facebook:  @greenmarked.it

 

© GreenMarked.it is managed by ECONTROVERTIA APS — Via Alcide De Gasperi 1, 38015 Lavis (TN), Italy — VAT IT02667560227